Skip to main content
 
Support our workStand with every
community in Burma
Donate →
Digital Hate monthly report 19 December 2023

November 2023 - Digital Hate Monthly Report

909 views
Share FacebookXWhatsApp
Cover: November 2023 - Digital Hate Monthly Report
In this report
  1. Introduction
  2. Methodology
  3. Findings of hate speech in Social Networks
  4. The figure illustrating types of hate speech
  5. The figure illustrating the number of hate speech targets
  6. Keywords used by hate speech writers
  7. Conclusion

1Introduction

The Myanmar military and its supporters have been spreading religious hate speeches targeting ethnic groups and religious minorities to make division and disunion among the revolutionary forces, which led to weaken the revolution. The junta is disseminating its ideology using hate speech. Moreover, 2021 coup accelerated persecution, marginalization and violence against minorities. The junta is using hate speech as a tool to create fear and disunion among the communities. The military is trying to keep its power longer by targeting ethnic and religious groups.

The junta and its supporters are circulating hate speeches in various ways, via both online and printed media, to divert the public attention from the revolution.

The objective of the BHRN monthly report is to monitor and analysis hate speeches circulated by the military and its supporters. BHRN documented a total of 131 hate speech cases in November 2023.

2Methodology

As hate speech is a term that comes from emotion, there is a wide spectrum in defining it, not a specific one. BHRN, therefore, standardizes the definition of hate speech for this report as follow. Hate speech in this report means aggressiveness and hatred against protected characteristics of a person or a group, blaming, discriminative expression, writing, gesture, or art expression of excoriation, or dehumanization.

It means attacking someone’s faith, language, gender, sexual orientation, origin, ethnicity, colour, race, belief, citizenship and physical appearance. The monitored hate speeches were categorized as (1) Criminalizing Hate Speech, (2) Abusive Hate Speech, (3) Dehumanizing Hate Speech, (4) Violence Inciting Hate Speech, (5) Threatening Hate Speech, and (6) Hate Speech that supports prejudicial actions inspired by hate speech.

BHRN has daily documented hate speech terms and usages found in the contents – based on the current political crisis - disseminated by the military.

This report was written after monitoring both online and printed media which were used by military supporters to spread their hate speeches. Especially, BHRN has monitored 15 Facebook Pages, 54 Facebook Accounts, 9 Tiktok Accounts, 28 Telegram Channels and 4 Printed Media during November.

Junta Disseminating Methodology

The Myanmar junta is using hate speech to boost its propagative mechanism. The propagative mechanism includes repeating something again and again, dominating mentality, deception and manipulating the data. By using those techniques, the Myanmar junta is creating narratives that promote their image as “the protector of the nation and the religion”.

The junta is using hate speech to stimulate serious emotions such as aggressiveness, fear and indignation. The junta is using those emotions to create hatred against its targeted area and organizations by means of fabricated cases and distortive information. This can lead to giving up and disunion among revolutionists.

This disunion will lead to the situation that which the people focus on raising questions and blaming each other among the community rather than focusing on fighting against persecuted policies of the military.

Context of misinformation as hate speech

In this report, BHRN has analysed hate speech in the context of the ongoing political tensions in Myanmar. Sometimes, when measured by international standards, what might look like misinformation takes on a different significance in the aftermath of the 2021 coup. This is because misinformation, particularly when aimed at individuals, groups with opposing political beliefs, or minority religious communities, can have severe consequences, even leading to loss of life and the intensification of religious and community conflicts.

Hate speech in Myanmar's current political climate is more than just false information; it can be a catalyst for very real and harmful outcomes, especially in the post-coup environment. Understanding this complex relationship between hate speech, misinformation, and their tangible impacts is crucial for grasping the region's broader social, political, and intergroup dynamics.

3Findings of hate speech in Social Networks

A total of 131 hate speech cases were found during BHRN’s monitoring process this month. When Facebook accounts were disabled, some created new accounts and some moved to Telegram channels. The military mainly used Telegram channels to do propaganda and the propaganda was done through the cartoons more in this month.

In this month’s monitoring, hate speech targeted the most was the Muslim community and the second was PDF and the third was EAOs. Moreover, hate speeches targeting Ethnic groups, Rohingyas, Women, LGBT, and the Christian Community were found as well.

In addition, the most used terms of hate speech for this month are "terrorist, dog, cow, fugitive, the one who does not eat pork, Shit Kalar (a derogatory term referring to Muslim), gay, Mus Kalar, rapist, dog Kalar, lied ethnic, illegal Bengali, bastard and bandit.”

Hate Speeches Targeting Muslim Community

Hate Speeches found on Tiktok

Ko Kyaw Wanna TikTok Account posted hate speech that “Hamas is a terrorist Kalar and they rape the girls after kidnapping them. This evil method is the way of Muslims.” The post was related to the Israel-Palestine crisis. That post used Dehumanizing Hate Speech against Hamas by comparing them to dogs. It also wrote, “Stand with Israel.”

Ko Kyaw Wanna Tiktok Account Post

Translation Original Post

Myanmarmalay Tiktok's account posted that “Muslims are dangers to Buddhist Monks not only in Myanmar but also in Bangladesh and Thailand so that when the Buddhist people speak out that they have painful feelings against Muslims, we are accused of spreading religious hatred. Buddhist people have painful feelings against Muslims because Muslims are united, for example, Muslims in Myanmar support Palestinian people. Buddhist people will not hate Muslims if they do not assassinate Buddhist monks.” Muslims are accused of attacking Buddhist monks. The post used Criminalizing Hate Speech against Muslims by portraying them as the assassinators of Buddhist monks.

TikTok Account Post

Translation Original Post

Findings of hate speech in Social Networks

Ulama Islamic Religious Organization in Pathein Township of Ayeyarwaddy Region announced that Pyigyimandaing Restaurant is no longer in line with Halal Standard and its Rules, and Muslims should not eat in that Restaurant. In that case, MyanmarMalay TikTok account posted a hate speech that “ethnic people should be clever that Muslim Restaurants are taking ethnic people’s money and they do not wish to pay back. Muslim Restaurants should be boycotted.” That post used Criminalizing Hate Speech against the Muslim community.

Myanmarmalay Tiktok Post

Translation Original Post

MyanmarMalay Tiktok's account posted hate speech that “Muslims should learn the concept of Nateban (means ‘heaven’) first then use that word. Mosque leaders lied that someone can go to heaven by just prostrating five times a day and killing cows without putting any effort.” That post used Criminalizing Hate Speech against Muslims.

Myanmarmalay Tiktok Account Post

Translation Original Post

Hate Speeches Targeting the Kachin Independence Army (KIA), Arakan Army (AA) and Myanmar National Democratic Alliance Army (MNDAA)

Thazinoo Telegram Channel posted hate speech by comparing the Kachin Independence Army (KIA) to dogs in a so-called poem. The literal meaning of the poem is “KIA is relying on foreigners and they are bastards. The town of Laiza was fired and it should be attacked till it becomes a clear ground. Dog Gwanmaw (KIA leader) is just shouting loud.” That post used Dehumanizing Hate Speech against KIA by comparing them to dogs.

Thazinoo Telegram Channel Link

Translation Original Post

Findings of hate speech in Social Networks

Mahuyar Mwayhauk Telegram Channel posted that “terrorist Chinese TNLA was attacked by military’s eagle force. A total of 2000 dead bodies of terrorist PDF and Chinese Sniffer dog TNLA was found during that attack”. The post used Dehumanizing Hate Speech against the Ta’ang National Liberation Army (TNLA) by comparing them to dogs, moreover, PDF was devalued as PDat.

Mahuyar Mwayhauk Telegram Channel Post

Translation Original Post

Western 24 News Telegram Channel posted hate speech that “As AA is in starvation, its lobbyists are creating narratives that encourage AA to become bandits against the civilians. Even though AA was weaponized in the name of ethnic affairs, they finally become bandits in the way that their teacher KIA has done.” The post used Criminalizing Hate Speech against the Arakan Army (AA) and Kachin Independence Army (KIA).

Western 24 News Telegram Channel Post

Translation Original Post

Justice Seeker Group Telegram Channel posted hate speech “As three-monkey group becomes weak, these dog ethnics killed civilians and they are trying to blame military for that according to their dog’s idea. They are spreading fake news that the military killed those civilians”. That post used Dehumanizing Hate Speech against the Myanmar National Democratic Alliance Army (MNDAA), Ta’ang National Liberation Army (TNLA) and Arakan Army (AA) by comparing them to dog and monkey.

Justice Seeker Group Telegram Post

Translation Original Post

Hate Speeches Targeting Women

Military Record Telegram Channel posted that “Beautiful PDF girls should not be killed but arrested alive. If this kind of beautiful ones are arrested, even the interrogation officers might have to fight for who to do the interrogation process.” That post used Sexually Abusive Hate Speech against women.

Military Record Telegram Channel

Translation Original Post

Naypyitaw Telegram Channel posted hate speech that “Celebrity Hla Nu Htun must be taken away from her bedstead and put her on the Insein bedsheet.” That post used Sexually Abusive Hate Speech against women.

Naypyitaw Telegram Channel Post

Translation Original Post

Kyaw Swar Telegram Channel posted hate speech that “This pig is happy for bomb explosion. She lives in Homeland street of Sanchaung Township and works at UniTinn ship company”. It was posted because she shared a news about bomb explosion. That post used Dehumanized Hate Speech against women by comparing her to the pig.

Kyaw Swar Telegram Channel Post

Translation Original Post

KyarPauk Tiktok Account posted hate speech by using NUG Foreigner Minister Daw Zin Mar Aung’s photo “This woman in crew cut hair is shouting out everywhere like the dog that does not get a place to sleep. How much does she get for one shout out?”. That posed used Abusive and Dehumanized Hate Speech against the woman by comparing her to the dog that does not get a place to sleep.

Kyarpouk Post

Translation Original Post

Findings of hate speech in Social Networks

Hate Speech in Cartoons

Military lobbyists are using more cartoons to spread hate speech lately.

(1) Justice Seeker Group Telegram Channel posted that “fugitive NUG terrorist group and their leaders become rich. They are saying that the revolution has reached a lot. NUG ministers are using donated money for their self-benefits while ground fighters are misused and killed for leaders’ benefits.” That post used Abusive Hate Speech in a cartoon. That cartoon was drawn by Maga.

Justice Seeker Group Telegram Channel Post

Translation Original Post

(2) A pro-military Telegram Channel named “Han Nyein Oo” posted that “the dogs adopted by KIA are attacking civilians and the places where people live. They are evils and subhuman.” That post was related to the armed organizations operating against the military in the southern Shan State. That hate speech cartoon used Dehumanizing Hate Speech against MNDAA, TNLA, and AA by comparing them to dogs.

Hannyeinoo Telegram Channel Post

Translation Original Post

(3) A pro-military Telegram Channel named “Han Nyein Oo” posted that “As terrorist AA is in dog status, they do not know to help and protect their people.” That post used Dehumanizing Hate Speech against the Arakan Army by comparing them to dogs.

Hannyeinoo Telegram Post

Translation Original Post

Findings of hate speech in Social Networks

(4) A pro-military Telegram Channel named Ka Ka Han posted that “People are no longer accepting you a terrorist (PDF) who threat and kill civilians by using the money you collected from civilians.” That hate speech cartoon used Criminalizing Hate Speech against PDF.

Ka Ka Han Telegram Channel Post

Translation Original Post

Hate Speech Targeting Rohingya Community

PAN Telegram Channel posted hate speech that “A total of 167 illegally migrated Bengali and 10 boat crews were arrested from two suspected boats in the northern south ocean of Myatmawtin Pagoda, Hainggyikyun Township.” That post used Criminalizing Hate Speech against Rohingya by mentioning them as illegally migrated people.

PAN Telegram Channel Post

Translation Original Post

An ultra-nationalist activist named Naungtawlay posted on his Naungtawlay Telegram Channel that “Nationalist movements became active in Myanmar because of terrorist activities of illegal Bengali.” That hate speech used Criminalizing Hate Speech against Rohingya by portraying them as illegally migrated people.

Naung Taw Lay Post Screenshot

Translation Original Post

Mahuyar Mwayhauk Telegram Channel posted hate speech that “Rohingya are striving their best to convert Rakhine State to Arakanistan.

Mahuyar Mwayhauk Telegram Channel posted hate speech that “Rohingya are striving their best to convert Rakhine State to Arakanistan. The leaders of the Rakhine Arakan Army are also collaborating in that conspiracy and these leaders are making their ethnic people flee away.” That post used Criminalizing Hate Speech against Rohingya that they are striving to colonize Rakhine State by collaborating with AA.

Mahuyar Mwayhauk Telegram Channel Post

Translation Original Post

Findings of hate speech in Social Networks

4The figure illustrating types of hate speech

The figure illustrating types of hate speech

5The figure illustrating the number of hate speech targets

The figure illustrating the number of hate speech targets

6Keywords used by hate speech writers

Keywords used by hate speech writers

7Conclusion

The pro-military channels posted more hate speeches against armed organizations in those areas where civil wars happened between military and resistance armed organizations. Moreover, it was written that Rohingya are dangerous to Rakhine State by collaborating with AA. It was found that more hate speeches were created to make lack of trust among AA, Rohingya and Civilians when it comes to establishing people administration and civil wars become more intense. In addition, it was found that the women participating in the revolution were sexually abused as well.

About BHRN

Burma Human Rights Network (BHRN) is based in London, operates across Burma/Myanmar and works for human rights, minority rights and religious freedom in Burma. BHRN has played a crucial role in advocating for human rights and religious freedom with politicians and world leaders.

Media enquiries

Kyaw WinExecutive DirectorBurma Human Rights Network (BHRN)This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.+44(0) 740 345 2378
Follow BHRN

Get our latest press releases and reports.

More Digital Hate monthly reports

All Digital Hate monthly reports →