Skip to main content
 
Support our workStand with every
community in Burma
Donate →
Digital Hate monthly report 17 November 2023

October 2023 - Digital Hate Monthly Report

881 views
Share FacebookXWhatsApp
Cover: October 2023 - Digital Hate Monthly Report
In this report
  1. Introduction
  2. Methodology
  3. Findings of hate speech in Social Networks
  4. The figure illustrating types of hate speech
  5. The figure illustrating the number of hate speech targets
  6. Keywords used by hate speech writers
  7. Conclusion

1Introduction

The Burmese military and its supporters have been spreading religious hate speech targeting ethnic groups and religious minorities to cause division among the revolutionary forces, and it is intended to weaken the unity among the opposition groups. While persecution on minorities in Burma has been typical military's policy, the 2021 coup accelerated persecution, marginalisation, and violence against minorities. The military uses the divide and rule strategy to maintain its power stronger by targeting religious minorities.

The junta and its supporters are circulating hate speeches in various ways via both online and printed media. Online media is spread on websites and apps, including Facebook, TikTok, and Telegram.

The objective of BHRN’s monthly report is to monitor and analyse hate speech circulated by the military and its supporters. BHRN documented 109 hate speech cases in October 2023.

2Methodology

Hate speech is a term that involves emotion, and there is a wide spectrum of ways to define it, not a specific one. BHRN, therefore, standardises the definition of hate speech for this report as follows: Hate speech in this report means expression, writing, gestures, or art that directs scorn, dehumanization, scapegoating, aggressiveness, violence, and hatred against protected characteristics of a person or a group.

Hate speech means targeting someone based on faith, language, gender, sexual orientation, origin, ethnicity, colour, race, belief, citizenship, or physical appearance. BHRN categorised monitored hate speech as (1) Criminalizing Hate Speech, (2) Abusive Hate Speech, (3) Dehumanizing Hate Speech, (4) Violence Inciting Hate Speech, (5) Threatening Hate Speech, and (6) Hate Speech that supports prejudicial actions inspired by hate speech.

BHRN has documented hate speech terms and usages found in the contents based on the current political crisis - disseminated by the military.

BHRN completed this report by monitoring online and printed media that military supporters used to spread their hate speech. In particular, BHRN monitored 14 Facebook Pages, 52 Facebook Accounts, 7 Tiktok Accounts, 23 Telegram Channels and 4 Printed Media.

Junta Disseminating Methodology

The Burmese junta is using hate speech to boost its propaganda mechanism. The propaganda mechanism includes frequent repetition, domination of thought, deception, and data manipulation. Using these techniques, the junta creates narratives promoting their image as “the protector of the nation and the religion.”

The junta uses hate speech to stimulate strong emotions such as aggressiveness, fear, and indignation. The junta uses those emotions to create hatred against its targeted area and organizations using fabricated cases and distortive information. This process is intended to lower morale and cause disunion among revolutionists and opposition.

This disunion is intended to cause people to focus on suspicion and blame towards each other in their communities rather than concentrating on fighting against the oppressive policies of the military.

Context of misinformation as hate speech

In this report, BHRN has analysed hate speech in the context of the ongoing political tensions in Myanmar. Sometimes, when measured by international standards, what might look like misinformation takes on a different significance in the aftermath of the 2021 coup. This is because misinformation, particularly when aimed at individuals, groups with opposing political beliefs, or minority religious communities, can have severe consequences, even leading to loss of life and the intensification of religious and community conflicts.

Hate speech in Myanmar's current political climate is more than just false information; it can be a catalyst for very real and harmful outcomes, especially in the post-coup environment. Understanding this complex relationship between hate speech, misinformation, and their tangible impacts is crucial for grasping the region's broader social, political, and intergroup dynamics.

3Findings of hate speech in Social Networks

A total of 109 hate speech cases were found during our monitoring process this month. When accounts were disabled, some created new accounts, and some moved to Telegram channels. The military mainly used Telegram channels to spread propaganda. This month, BHRN monitored the increased use of cartoons to spread misinformation or hate speech.

Hate speech Targets and term usage

During this month's monitoring, the People’s Defense Forces (PDF) was the largest target of hate speech. The PDF is a revolutionary armed group that formed after the 2021 coup. Its members are primarily students, activists, and regular civilians. The second greatest target of hate speech was the Kachin Independence Army (KIA). The KIA is an ethnic armed organisation (EAO) composed of ethnic Kachin, a majority Christian ethnic community. The third most targeted group was the National Unity Government (NUG). The NUG is composed of remaining members of the political opposition to the Burmese junta, mainly in the diaspora. BHRN also monitored significant use of hate speech against the Karen National Union (KNU), Muslims, Rohingya, the Ta’Ang National Liberation Army (TNLA), the Myanmar National Democratic Alliance Army (MNDAA), and the Arakan Army (AA). All of these groups represent ethnic, religious, and political groups that are oppressed by the Burmese junta.

The most frequently used terms to demonise or dehumanise groups this month were: Terrorists, dogs, those who don't eat pork, murderers, fugitive groups, militants, and state traitors. The term “Kalar,” which is a racist term commonly used against Rohingya and other Muslims, has been blocked by Facebook, so its usage has likewise declined online.

Hate speeches targeting the Muslim community

U Pyinyar, an ultra-nationalist monk, posted on his Facebook account that “no matter what anyone says about the Palestine - Israel conflict, he stands with Israel, who is killing the EID dogs (referring to Muslims who celebrate EID).” He used Dehumanizing Hate Speech against Palestinian Muslims and Muslims generally.

U Pyinnyar Account Original Post Post Translation

Findings of hate speech in Social Networks

MyanmarMaLay’s TikTok account posted that “the PDF and the military are currently blaming each other as monks are being killed constantly. It said that if others are killed, the murderer is identified, but when monks are killed, the murderer is unknown. The post raises unsupported fears that the PDF is targeting Buddhists.” The post also used Abusive Hate Speech against Muslims, saying not to turn a blind eye to the Muslims who are profiting from the revolution.

TikTok Account Original Post Post Translation

Yan Naing Magway’s account posted that “because of the Palestine-Israel war, there were conflicts between Muslims living in the United States and the United Kingdom and their native citizens. The reason is that Muslims support the Palestinians, but the local citizens support Israel. There were attacks due to this disagreement. In Myanmar, the 1947, 1974, and 2008 constitutions grant every citizen the right to profess and practice their religious beliefs freely, and the number of mosques allowed for Muslims in Myanmar exceeds the number of mosques in Indonesia. The Burma Citizenship Act 1982 granted citizenship to Muslims as well. Although Burmese people, Buddhists, are nice to the Muslims, why do Muslims stand at the top of the list in destroying Myanmar? Why do Muslims want to be in an ethnic group when they are not among the 135 ethnic groups? He warned the guests (refers to Muslims) not to insult the host (refers to Buddhists) and not to destroy Burmese people after drinking Burmese water, consuming Burmese rice, and breathing Burmese air. He portrayed Muslims as criminals, saying that Muslims are just unwanted guests in Myanmar, they commit violence in all places of the world and they are always trying to destroy the Burmese people and the country.” He used Criminalizing Hate Speech against the Muslim community.

Yan Naing Magway Account Original Post Post Translation

MyanmarMaLay’s TikTok account posted that “even though we (Burmese people) are at each other's throats, you 200,000 Bengalis have to flee to the sea. So, when we (Burmese) are on the same page, you Muslims have to prepare to be officially stateless. Don't even think about touching us with the excuse of our internal conflict. You (Muslims) will have to pay tenfold for what you did if you dare to touch us. She used Violence Inciting Hate Speech, which can lead to riots. She added that it is our internal affair, even if we attack each other. However, once we hear Muslims attack us, we all will turn to them together.”

The post used Threatening Hate Speech against the Muslim community.

Tiktok account Original Post Post Translation

Findings of hate speech in Social Networks

Hate speeches targeting armed organizations cause them to lose public trust

A pro-military user, Han Nyein Oo, telegram channel posted a hate speech cartoon drawn by cartoonist Idea. The cartoon portrayed PDFs as murderers, thieves, and criminals who cause trouble to people. The picture of the NUG acting president was drawn in a Kachin uniform. In the cartoon, the media interviewed him, and he said that NUG was protecting the armed groups that are affiliated with them, even if those armed groups commit crimes. That cartoon was expressed with the background images of a school being destroyed, a nurse being killed, and property being stolen by the PDF. That post used Criminalizing Hate Speech against NUG and PDF.

Han Nyein Oo Channel Original Post Post Translation

A pro-military Telegram Channel named “Mhinewei” posted that “the monk from Pintint Village near Mandalay-Myitkyina Highway Road, Indaw Township, was arrested and killed by KIA/PDF.” He portrayed KIA/PDF as criminals who are attacking Buddhism. That post had 32.6K viewers.

Telegram Channel Original Post Post Translation

A pro-military Telegram Channel called “Mhinewei” posted that “it seemed that KIA and KNU terrorist groups were intentionally creating religious riots. The KNU+PDF killed a Buddhist-Karen man and a woman in their house in Park Street, Ward No.4, Myawaddy Township. It was observed that the KNU terrorist group was mainly killing the Buddhists. Last year, the pilgrims who visited Kyikehtiyo Pagoda were shot and killed in order to lessen the number of pilgrims. Bridges along the mountain road were mined repeatedly to block the Buddhist pilgrims. They also robbed all the donation money at the Kyikehtiyo Pagoda to buy the weapons.

The KIA is killing the Buddhist monks in Sagaing Region almost every day. KIA and KNU groups are working to fade Buddhism away.” He used a Criminalizing Hate Speech against KIA + KNU, saying that they were converting from anti-coup groups to anti-Buddhist groups. That post had 43K viewers.

Telegram Channel Original Post Post Translation

Findings of hate speech in Social Networks

A pro-military Telegram Channel named “Sittway” posted that “MNDAA, TNLA, AA and PDF are intentionally shooting down the civilian areas such as Kut Khaing Power Plant in northern Shan state, Lashio, a city gate, a high school, a hospital that provides daily medical treatments to the locals, market, station, the densely populated Ward (9) with missiles, and these terrorists are giving all kinds of troubles to the people.” He used Abusive Hate Speech against the armed forces that are fighting the junta. That post had 2.5K viewers.

Telegram Channel Original Post Post Translation

A pro-military channel named “Ko Thet” posted that “Gun Gun (a feminine term and reference to KIA General Gun Maw) does not know the high-quality standard food produced by the military because they are only able to eat rotten food in the forest. The products produced by the military are long-life foods and higher-quality products. The gay Gun Gun is jealous because he has a woman’s mindset, and he should be called Gun Gun.” That hate speech was posted after General Gun Maw showed the expiration date of the food found in a Burmese military base after the KIA seized it. This hate speech labeled General Gun Maw as feminine and gay, portraying the LGBT community as criminal while also being misogynistic. He used Criminalizing Hate Speech and Abusive Hate Speech against the LGBT+ Community.

Telegram Channel Original Post Post Translation

Hate speeches targeted to Rohingya

A pro-military Telegram Channel named “Nayeemoe” analysed the Palestine-Israel war and added that “Rakhine is the state that has the most intercommunal conflicts in Myanmar. There are illegal Bengali in different parts of Myanmar. The population of Bengali in Buthidaung and Maungdaw Townships of Rakhine State has largely increased nowadays compared to their population at the time of the first Bengali-Rakhine war. As international recognition is one of the five pillars of building a new state, Myanmar is in a very alarming situation. International affairs are to be carefully observed, and internal affairs can be international affairs in the future. Systematic protections are needed before it breaks out. Rohingyas are illegal migrants. Therefore, preventions are essential as they are living inside the country.” That telegram post used Criminalized Hate Speech against the Rohingya community, and that post had 30.7K views.

Telegram Channel Original Post Post Translation

A pro-military Facebook Account named “Thurein Oo” posted that “A third World War is surely coming because the world population is largely increasing and it needs to be reduced. Those particular countries that follow the religion that allows four wives for a man are strategically trying to dominate the world by their huge birth rates and populations.

The original people of Europe have been fleeing from their places because of migrants and invaders from different religions over the last two decades. In Buthidaung and Maungdaw Townships of Rakhine State, Rakhine people are running away from their lands because of the illegal migrants and invaders with large birth-rate.” The Rohingya are portrayed as invaders and criminals in the post. It was a Criminalizing Hate Speech.

Facebook Account Original Post Post Translation

A pro-military Telegram Channel named “Ko Thet” posted that “Israel was established on Arab land. Israel has been seizing Arab lands throughout the years. When the Arabs attack Israel now, Israel fights back with its military. The Western countries said that Israel is defending their country and people. Rakhine State was the land of the Rakhine people and other ethnic groups. The Bengalis have been invading the land throughout the years. The villages with Rakhine names have become Bengali villages. Extremist Bengalis organized ARSA in 2017 and attacked four security bases with the military support of foreign lands. Myanmar military fought them back. The protection of our own country and people has been labeled as Genocide by the Western countries.” That post used Criminalizing Hate Speech against the Rohingya Community, and that post had 42K viewers.

TelegramChannel OriginalPost

Post Translation

Findings of hate speech in Social Networks

4The figure illustrating types of hate speech

The figure illustrating types of hate speech

5The figure illustrating the number of hate speech targets

The figure illustrating the number of hate speech targets

6Keywords used by hate speech writers

Keywords used by hate speech writers

7Conclusion

The Israel-Palestine conflict was a recurring theme in October, which was used to cause fear of Muslims and Rohingya, who they claim are exploiting the conflict in Burma. The military and its supporters are spreading propaganda that armed ethnic organisations are terrorists targeting civilians and Buddhists in particular. The common theme in the propaganda is that Buddhism is under threat by groups the junta marginalises or is in conflict with. The junta then promoted itself as the protector of the people and Buddhism.

About BHRN

Burma Human Rights Network (BHRN) is based in London, operates across Burma/Myanmar and works for human rights, minority rights and religious freedom in Burma. BHRN has played a crucial role in advocating for human rights and religious freedom with politicians and world leaders.

Media enquiries

Kyaw WinExecutive DirectorBurma Human Rights Network (BHRN)This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.+44(0) 740 345 2378
Follow BHRN

Get our latest press releases and reports.

More Digital Hate monthly reports

All Digital Hate monthly reports →